Airbnb: 6 Lessons Learnt from Bad Airbnb Guests - A Cosy Garden Cottage (2024)

Posted on November 29, 2019August 22, 2020 by Lucienne

Last Updated on August 22, 2020 by Lucienne

This post is part 2 of 3 in my story about the worst Airbnb guests ever. In part 1 I give a horror account of the weekend where we endured the most terrible Airbnb guests in our Cosy Garden Cottage. Part 3 I share a step by step guide on how I used the Airbnb Resolution Center to claim my damages back from these guests.

This part 2 is the rest of the story and my six lessons learnt from these bad Airbnb guests.

The week that followed the worst guests ever

Monday. Off I set to go and replace what has been damaged. Armed with several photos and the slips I put in my request for additional money to the guest. Ahhh! I can’t put in a second request until the guest as accepted or declined my initial request for the additional pax for the two nights.

Tuesday. No surprises. The guest declines my request for additional money for the additional two pax. What a cheek! I submit my second request for additional money under the damages option making sure I load all my photographs and till slips for evidence. I take a deep breath and explain in my kindest words why I think the guest ought to refund me for the damages. What are the chances they are going to accept this claim when it is four times more than my initial claim?!

Wednesday. Ping goes the Airbnb app on my phone. Well I never?! The guest has accepted my request for refund for the damages. I know that Airbnb have been mediating with the guest, I am not sure what they said, but I am thrilled they have got my claim accepted.

5 minutes later. Ping! There goes the app again. Is it a booking? No such luck. The payment for the damages from the guest has not gone through. Infuriating. Ping! Now what?! Airbnb: We are having trouble recovering the money from your guest but we are doing everything we can to resolve the issue. Oh, dear.

Happy ending at last

Thursday. Ping! The money for the damages has been paid into my account. I am thrilled to bits! All the money for the linen and glasses that I had to replace has been recovered. I am not sure what happened but I can only imagine that Airbnb replaced my funds and the amount is now sitting as a credit against the guest. Surely the guest won’t be able to make another booking until Airbnb has recovered their funds? Pleased with my outcome, I decide it is time to write that review I have been stewing over since Sunday…

6 lessons learnt from bad Airbnb guests

  1. ALWAYS review the booking and check that it reflects the right number of people. I had got too trusting and complacent. If you do see a problem on the booking you need to make the request for changes before the day of checkout.
  2. If you feel the stay is not going well always refer to written communication through the Airbnb app. This will come through as great evidence to back your case should you need Airbnb to mediate in your situation.
  3. You cannot put more than one request for money in at a time with any given guest. The guest will have to accept or decline the request before a second request can be submitted.
  4. If someone trashes your place take loads of photos before you start to clean up. The more photographic evidence you have to submit to Airbnb, the more likely they will be able to refund you for your damages.
  5. If and when you do need to replace items be sure to take photos of your till slips and submit those with your photos so that Airbnb and the guest can see what the replacements cost you.
  6. When in doubt about a guest or booking, phone Airbnb and ask for guidance on what you need to do to get your problem resolved. I found all the agents I dealt with very helpful.

After telling my story to some of my fellow hosting friends I discovered that not everyone knows about the Airbnb Resolution Centre, let alone how to use it. In Part 3 of this story I give a detailed ‘how to’ guide with screenshots of the steps I followed.

Have you ever had shocking guests? How did you deal with them and what lessons did you learn? I’d love to hear from you.

In Part 1 of my story you can read my account of the worst Airbnb guests ever.

Other posts you may be interested in:

5 ways to make money on Airbnb without owning property

10 special touches that get five star reviews

Writing that all important guest welcome book

  1. Well, Airbnb guest are mainly nice people. The worst I had were people who didn t take their ID when going on a trip, the police called me. In the end they were released from the station, after I confirmed their ID and that they rented my place. sh*t happens.

    Reply

    1. Hi Latifa,
      Gosh, that must have been an administrative nightmare! I am glad you were able to sort it out. Fortunately my Airbnb guests are mainly nice people too, just the odd bad egg has thought me a lesson or two.
      Thanks for sharing.
      Luci

      Reply

  2. Hi Lucienne!
    Just read your post. OMG!!!! I’ve been hosting since 2009 with AirBnB and have been super lucky (knock on wood). It is for sure, a follow your gut kind of business.
    I have a question… Do you require a security deposit? Is that how AirBnB was able to assist with making a claim?
    I have never required a security deposit, though sometimes think I’m being a bit risky and too trusting. Seriously considering it now as I have moved to the coast and my rental (The Surf House) is attracting super young kids (the last bunch left just minutes ago and feeling anxiety as I am about to go check out the situation). My prior rental was a Glamping site and was almost always just couples or young families. My other listings in the past have been rooms in my home.
    Would love your insight. Honestly, I wanted to cry for you when I saw your photos.
    Warmest regards,
    Leslie

    Reply

    1. Hi Leslie,
      It was a shocking experience to say the least! But I was so glad that I was able to claim from Airbnb. I didn’t ask for a security deposit and I was still able to claim. I think the key was that I got hold of Airbnb before the guests left as my gut told me it wasn’t going to be pretty. Fortunately the consultant I spoke to told me to take loads of photographic evidence (which you can see I did) and that really helped to make my case with Airbnb.
      I know that one can ask for a security deposit in the settings but I haven’t set it up as I think I might lose bookings. A bit risky I know but a totally personal choice that I have made. Perhaps try it for a while? Especially with ‘the surf house’, see what impact it has on your bookings and then weigh it off? Like you say there is no definite science to this business and a whole lot of gut!
      I hope the kids left your surf house spotless!
      Thanks for your support.
      Lucienne

      Reply

  3. Wow! That sounds like a nightmare! We are thinking of AirBnb for the in-law suite on our house. It is beautiful and I would be very upset if it were trashed… I like the fact that someone has your back, and sounds like the resolutions are satisfying. Still considering this venture, so will keep reading and researching!

    Reply

    1. Hi Donna,
      This was my absolute low with letting our cottage out to short term rentals. I have been doing this for just over 4 years now, and this was my worst experience. Some people have been doing it for much longer and have not had this kind of experience at all. For the most part people are very kind and considerate and I have made some wonderful friends through this business. Loads of research as you are doing is definitely a good idea. Good luck on making the decision that is best for you:)
      Thank you for your support.
      Lucienne

      Reply

  4. Very interesting and very useful advice! Thank you Luci.

    Reply

    1. Thank you for reading Deborah:)

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Airbnb: 6 Lessons Learnt from Bad Airbnb Guests - A Cosy Garden Cottage (2024)

FAQs

How to answer a bad review on Airbnb? ›

Just as there is an optimal way to respond to a positive review, there is also an optimal way to respond to a negative review.
  1. Do: Remove The Fluff.
  2. Don't: Respond Publicly To Private Feedback.
  3. Do: Address Issues Head-On.
  4. Don't: Be Accusatory.
  5. Do: Ignore Negative Feedback.
  6. Don't: Respond At Length.

What is an example of a bad review on Airbnb? ›

[Guest name] was extremely noisy and disruptive, which made it difficult for the neighbors to get a good night's sleep. I wouldn't host this guest again. [Guest name] left the place dirty and untidy.

What to write on an Airbnb review? ›

Highlight things like: Your interactions with your guest, Host, and their associates—were they pleasant and respectful? Anything that made the stay special, like cleanliness, personal touches, convenience, amazing coffee.

How to write a review for a bad guest? ›

Sadly, we had issues with [guest name]. They broke things and were very messy, which made hosting them very unpleasant. We would not recommend them to anyone and strongly advise against letting them stay in your property. This guest did not follow our clearly communicated house rules and was overall very disruptive.

How to respond to negative guest reviews? ›

How to respond to negative hotel reviews
  • Thank the guest by name. ...
  • Apologize for the guest's poor experience. ...
  • Highlight any changes you have made or intend to make. ...
  • Evaluate the need for follow up-procedures.
May 22, 2023

What to do if you are not happy with your Airbnb? ›

Ask for a refund: If you need to request a refund because of the issue, there's a higher chance your Host will accept your request if you can agree on an amount first. Send a request to your Host for the refund in the Resolution Center and provide the details of the issue along with the photos or video.

Can I kick out Airbnb guest? ›

You set the rules for your place—it's as simple as that. If you have a guest who has broken a house rule or done something to make you feel unsafe, you don't have to take their reservation.

How does Airbnb punish hosts? ›

Actions we take may include providing information to Hosts about this policy and issuing warnings. When repeated or severe violations of these ground rules are reported, Hosts or their listings may be suspended or removed from the platform.

What is the most common complaints of Airbnb? ›

5 Common Airbnb Complaints and How To Handle Them
  • Complaint #1: Issues With Cleanliness and Maintenance.
  • Complaint #2: Inaccurate or Misleading Property Descriptions.
  • Complaint #3: Problems With Check-In and Accessibility.
  • Complaint #4: Lack of Amenities or Supplies.
  • Complaint #5: Unresponsive or Unhelpful Hosts.
Mar 18, 2024

What is not allowed in Airbnb review? ›

The following content is not allowed on Airbnb:

Content that endorses or promotes illegal or harmful activity, or that is sexually explicit, violent, graphic, threatening, or harassing. Content that is discriminatory (review our Nondiscrimination Policy for more information)

Can you delete bad reviews on Airbnb? ›

While you can't remove a review, you can report it if you think it violates our Reviews Policy. Feel free to respond with more context or to provide your own perspective, so long as you, too, follow the Reviews Policy.

What is a good response to a bad Airbnb review? ›

Like this: 'thank you for your feedback' or 'I am always looking to improve as a host so I appreciate your honest feedback' or 'I always hope to improve my listing to make sure my guests have wonderful experiences. '

What is the best Airbnb review for guests sample? ›

"We highly recommend [Guest Name] as a guest. They were courteous, tidy and respectful of our home. We thoroughly enjoyed hosting them and would gladly welcome them back anytime." "[Guest Name] was a gracious guest who maintained the cleanliness of our home throughout their stay.

What do Airbnb hosts see about guests? ›

Before you book, a Host will only be shown your first name and identity verification status. Your full name and profile photo will be shared with the Host after your booking is confirmed.

What to do if you get an unfair review on Airbnb? ›

To report a review for violating this policy, contact us. If a review violates this policy, we may remove that review, including any associated ratings and other content. We take the removal of any review seriously and only do so where there is a clear violation of this policy.

Can you delete Airbnb reviews? ›

You can remove a review you published if it no longer reflects your genuine experience as a guest or Host. Just reach out to our customer support team with your request to remove a review you've authored.

Can you hide a bad review on Airbnb? ›

Can you remove a review from your page on Airbnb? You can't actually “hide” a bad review. The only way to remove it is to prove Airbnb that the guest violated their content policy.

How to deal with Airbnb complaints? ›

  1. Contact your Host or guest. Sending a message is usually the quickest and easiest way to resolve an issue with your listing or reservation. ...
  2. Explore the Help Center. Visit the Help Center to find answers to common questions, including information about: ...
  3. Visit the Resolution Center. ...
  4. Contact Airbnb Customer Service.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6212

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.